There are several arguments that come up repeatedly on Viking costuming forums. Many of them surround appropriate decoration techniques for costumes of the era (in contrast to things that are pure fantasy). Large scale embroidery is likely the most contentious of the techniques commonly employed by reenactors today. I have seen garments created and heavily embellished by individuals that were awe inspiring in their form and complexity, but realistically, there is no evidence for that type of work.
To begin this conversation, let me break down what we do know from archaeological evidence about garment embellishment:
We know that they had tablet woven bands.
There are dozens of band fragments from many areas ruled by the Vikings. Scandinavia, Ireland, York, Iceland even further east to places such as the Ukraine all have ample evidence of the use of tablet weaving. Most of these bands were brocaded, rather than the simple threaded-in patterns you commonly see used by reenactors. I have seen no evidence at all of decorative bands that use a method of simplistic 4 forward, 4 backward style of turning to create basic patterns such as diamonds. Rather, the patterning in most examples was created by brocading, a hand manipulating technique that produces an intricate design on the surface of the band, often executed with metallic thread (typically hammered silver or gold, or hammered metal wrapped around a silken core).
It is important to remember that there were only decorative bands found in less than 5% of graves, making even this type of treatment quite rare.
Most bands were less than a half an inch wide and were woven from silk, or a warp of half silk and half linen with the linen never showing on the surface. This allowed the weaver to use less of their costly silk while still creating a luxurious band. Wool has also been found as tablet woven bands.
To begin this conversation, let me break down what we do know from archaeological evidence about garment embellishment:
We know that they had tablet woven bands.
There are dozens of band fragments from many areas ruled by the Vikings. Scandinavia, Ireland, York, Iceland even further east to places such as the Ukraine all have ample evidence of the use of tablet weaving. Most of these bands were brocaded, rather than the simple threaded-in patterns you commonly see used by reenactors. I have seen no evidence at all of decorative bands that use a method of simplistic 4 forward, 4 backward style of turning to create basic patterns such as diamonds. Rather, the patterning in most examples was created by brocading, a hand manipulating technique that produces an intricate design on the surface of the band, often executed with metallic thread (typically hammered silver or gold, or hammered metal wrapped around a silken core).
It is important to remember that there were only decorative bands found in less than 5% of graves, making even this type of treatment quite rare.
Most bands were less than a half an inch wide and were woven from silk, or a warp of half silk and half linen with the linen never showing on the surface. This allowed the weaver to use less of their costly silk while still creating a luxurious band. Wool has also been found as tablet woven bands.
 |  |
Extant bands from Birka. (from Birka III: Die Textilfunde aus den Gräbern)
Tablet weaving on a mantle ribbon (Mammen). Photo credit - National Museum of Denmark
I personally have only had limited experience with tablet weaving, though adding brocading to my skill set is part of my eventual plan. I fault no one for using their learning attempts (typically simple threaded in patterns) to embellish their garb, and have done so myself because I prefer to use everything I make, even if it is a ‘learning process’ type of project. Indeed, I think this style of handwork still makes a better addition to a costume and purchased jacquard trim! I do, however, think it important for those who seek to improve their overall historic impression to understand what techniques were actually employed and work to master those.
 My simple tablet woven band in 24/2 wool. The technique used for this is not evidenced in the Viking age. |  The expertly crafted brocaded, tablet woven belt that is my apprentice belt. It is fine silk and based on one of the Birka finds. My Laurel is amazingly talented! Photo credit to Daniel Spies. |
Ideas for using tablet weaving to create a more accurate impression:
Part 2 can be found here: http://awanderingelf.weebly.com/a-wandering-elfs-journey/viking-embellishment-and-embroidery-part-2
- Use narrow bands (most finds were half an inch or less)
- Stick to silk, wool or linen when possible (or cost saving substitutes such as tencel for silk), and use very fine rather than thick threads
- Use brocading techniques to create motifs on the band or explore other methods of patterning done in period
- Choose your colors based on those available with natural dyes
- Only apply silk tablet woven bands to garments made from high quality textiles
- Opting to only use bands on a small portion of your kit, rather than decorating every available edge with a band, as the finds were rare
Part 2 can be found here: http://awanderingelf.weebly.com/a-wandering-elfs-journey/viking-embellishment-and-embroidery-part-2
RSS Feed