A Wandering Elf
  • A Wandering Elf
  • Blog: My Journey
  • Iron Age Celtic Studies
  • A Wandering Elf in the Woods
  • Classes
  • Resources: Sheep & Wool
  • Resources: Costume and Textiles
  • Resources: Migration Era
  • Resources: Historic Glass Beads

Food for Thought - "Souvenir Hypothesis"

11/4/2016

1 Comment

 
A friend recently brought up an issue that is common among the SCA Middle and Near Eastern personas (and often, newcomers in general).  That issue is the persistent myth that if a persona is a merchant or trader or traveler of any sort that "anything goes" in terms of garments and adornment.  This also often becomes a matter of heated discussion within the Viking crowd, because of the travel, trade and raids that occurred. 

Unfortunately, "anything goes" is really nothing more than a myth for most people, times and places.

To break this down, one needs to look at both the culture and evidence from the perspective of the people of the past, and not through our modern filter.  Clothing, in period, was often an identifier of one's nationality, social status and, sometimes, religion.  Costume was an significant reflection of social identity.  If anything, I feel this was more important in mixed cultures (precisely the place where many would impose the "anything goes" theory) than in some other areas.

In Eva Andersson's work on the textiles at Birka ( she references what Inga Hagg and the Souvenir Hypothesis.  Andersson states:
Hagg objects to these interpretations, arguing that 'The regularity found in this costume, both chronologically and as regards material, ornamental features, garment combinations, etc. shows that we are dealing with a real costume tradition and not with phenomena of the chance kind that has hitherto been claimed. The "souvenir hypothesis" is also based on a way of reasoning that is actually erroneous. In the history of costume it is normally the case that dress mainly expresses two things in a highly traditional and deliberate way. One is the ethnic affiliation of the wearer. This is sufficiently attested in a great many works about both prehistoric dress and modern folk dress. For that reason alone we are not entitled to assume that the Vikings of Birka, while in foreign countries, abandoned their own costume in favour of something exotic .... There is equally little justification for the assumption that foreign merchants in Birka would have adopted Scandinavian dress' (Hagg 1983, 209£). The costumes in the Birka graves have several distinctive features and therefore cannot be said primarily to be a reflection of the wearer's ethnic origin. Hagg argues that Birka costume instead expressed the status of the wearer (Hagg 1983, 210ff.) and believes that 'in such circumstances it is necessary to investigate whether the Oriental elements of Birka costume 'which cannot easily be interpreted as ethnically conditioned and which can no longer be regarded as souvenirs of travels - may instead designate rank' (Hagg 1983,211).

In her work with viking jewelry, Draupnir's Sweat and Mardoll's Tears, Michele Hayeur Smith makes the statement:
Viking adornment falls under the heading of anti-fashion. It is the product of a traditional society. Like all traditional
societies, Viking anti-fashion adornment promotes group identity and affiliation as well as cultural distinction. It
conveys a sense of social stability to its members, as well as the values and beliefs of the community. It allows its
members to identify themselves with each other and express to the world where they belong.
So what does all of this mean? 

We need to look more closely at what evidence we do have.  Yes, there was trade!  Yes, there were incredible foreign items found in the context of Viking graves!  But it is very important to consider the item itself, the source of the item, whether or not it was repurposed, and, most importantly, look at it in context of the entire find.
  • One common example is Frankish belt mounts.  These items were sometimes repurposed as brooches, worn by women.  This eventually lead to local production of trefoil brooches, which became a status item during the Viking Age.  (Helle, 123)
Picture
Frankish belt mount found near Oslo.
Picture
Trefoil brooch from Norway
  • Another common example would be items imported from the British Isles.  Many of these items were once from horse harnesses or from items such as elaborate religious books.  As with the belt mounts, the were frequently also converted to brooches or belt fittings. 
  • Sometimes belt-strap ends were converted into brooches.  This to eventually lead to new style of brooches.
Picture
Bronze mount from a woman's grave in Norway. (Heen-petterson)
Picture
10th century tongue brooches from Iceland.
PictureCeltic brooch found in a Viking grave in Norway. (Glørstad, 32)
Hopefully the scant handful of items above show that often trade (or raid) goods were used as adornment in quite a different manner than originally intended.

Of course, items were sometimes used without revision.  There are ample examples of Celtic penannular brooches in Viking graves.  Likewise, Slavic pendants show up in graves from Birka that also contain the traditional oval brooches, items that signifies Norse dress.



Most important consideration

Looking at the overall context of items in the grave is, perhaps, the most important factor when planning to use foreign goods as part of your kit.  Key points to consider:
  • Social Status:  Most trade goods were found in upper class graves.  The rest of the kit should be commensurate with this social status.  Is the cloth for the clothing an appropriate weight, weave and color?  Do other types of decoration reflect this status as well?  Even if you choose to portray those few graves mentioned by Hagg in her work at Birka, it is good to note that those individuals were of the highest ranks, might have adopted foreign dress, to some extent, as a manner of showing their status.  Even then, it is bringing in something such as Byzantine dress and it is still not a hodge-podge of collected bits from numerous cultures.
  • Gender: Is the item appropriate for the gender of your persona?  Can the item you desire using be repurposed as something that makes more sense in context of gender? 
  • Moderation: I do not know of any one grave that has a dozen different foreign items covering a half dozen different locations (or worse, a half dozen centuries).  A strip of imported silk and an Irish brooch, for example, would be sufficient to show high status and foreign connections, without falling prey to the fallacy of "anything goes".  Choose these accent pieces carefully and apply them appropriately.

This post is meant only to be a quick summary on my thoughts on dress and foreign goods in Viking society. It is by no means comprehensive. I highly recommend looking at some of the references below, as well as further researching how dress historically reflected the social identity in any culture, for those who want to accurately portray a persona who would have traveled, or had access to, foreign goods.


References

Andersson Strand, Eva. Tools for Textile Production – from Birka and Hedeby. Stockholm, 2003. (Birka studies; No. 8).

Glørstad, Zanette Tsigaridas, ‘Sign of the Times? The Transfer and Transformation of Penannular Brooches in Viking Age Norway’, 2012, 37–41

Hayeur Smith, Michele. Draupnir's Sweat and Mardoll's Tears: An Archaeology of Jewellery, Gender and Identity in Viking Age Iceland, 2004.

Helle, Knut, The Cambridge History of Scandinavia, Issue 1, (Cambridge University Press). 2003.

Heen-pettersen, Aina Margrethe, ‘Insular Artefacts from Viking - Age Burials from Mid - Norway . A Review of Contact between Trøndelag and Britain and Ireland’, 2014

Skre, Dagfinn, ‘From Dorestad to Kaupang: Frankish Traders and Settlers in a 9th Century Scandinavian Town’, Dorestad in an International Framework, 1991, 131–35

Sorheim, Helge, ‘Three Prominent Norwegian Ladies with British Connections’, Acta Archaeologica, 82 (2011)
1 Comment
Catherine Raymond link
11/7/2016 12:23:31 pm

Thanks for addressing, however preliminarily, an issue that should be of more importance to reenactors/historical costumers (and to archaeologists, for that matter).

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About Me

    I am mother to a billion cats and am on journey to recreate the past via costume, textiles, culture and food.

    A Wandering Elf participates in the Amazon Associates program and a small commission is earned on qualifying purchases. 
    ​

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    March 2021
    February 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Categories

    All
    12th Night
    14th Century
    AEthelmearc
    Aprondress
    Awards
    Bog Dress
    Bronze Age
    Dance
    Dance Name
    Distaff
    Dyeing
    Embroidery
    Fiber Arts
    Flax Growing
    Food
    Glass
    Haberci
    Headcoverings
    Inspirations
    In The News
    Library
    List Of Links
    Machine Embroidery
    Metal Clay
    Mid Month Inspiration
    Migration Era/Iron Age
    My Documents
    Ottoman
    Ottoman Fabrics
    Pennsic
    Publications
    Research
    Rigid Heddle
    Sca
    SCA Camping
    SCA Forestry
    Sca Name
    Sca Newcomer
    Sewing
    Sheep
    Spinning
    Textile Charts
    Tips
    Totally Not SCA
    Viking
    Viking Bead Research
    Viking Costume: Beyond The Myth
    Viking Swatch Book
    Viking Textiles Looking Deeper
    Weaving
    Wool


      Email Updates

    Subscribe to Newsletter

    Blogroll of SCA & Costume Bloggers

    Below is a collection of some of my favorite places online to look for SCA and historic costuming information.

    More Amie Sparrow - 16th Century German Costuming


    Gianetta Veronese - SCA and Costuming Blog

    Grazia Morgano - 16th Century A&S

    Mistress Sahra -Dress From Medieval Turku 

    Hibernaatiopesäke

    Loose Threads: Cathy's Costume Blog

    Mistress Mathilde Bourrette - By My Measure: 14th and 15th Century Costuming

    More than Cod: Exploring Medieval Norway

    RSS Feed


Proudly powered by Weebly