A Wandering Elf
  • A Wandering Elf
  • Blog: My Journey
  • Iron Age Celtic Studies
  • A Wandering Elf in the Woods
  • Classes
  • Resources: Sheep & Wool
  • Resources: Costume and Textiles
  • Resources: Migration Era
  • Resources: Historic Glass Beads

The Vikings

3/4/2013

4 Comments

 
Picture
The History Channel has produced a miniseries called Vikings.  I have to say I had been looking forward to this not only because it is about Vikings (and has Gabriel Byrne in it!) but because I was rather impressed with how they handled the Hatfields & McCoys series.  Unfortunately, this show was more Game of Thrones than Hatfields & McCoys (which really, is not bad as I love GoT, but it is also really not "history").  Don't get me wrong, I did enjoy it for entertainment value.  But, I cannot help but wish they had paid a bit more attention to historic detail.

Even the preview photos worried me when it came to garb.  How they could be so very far off of any reasonable mark (and there is a broad range of what is reasonable given the limited amount of extant data that we have) in terms of women's clothing just sorta baffles me.  There is excellent research out there and many experts in the field piecing these things together, I guess it was wrong of me to expect the History channel to access these resources.  Additionally, there are also some very nice things in museums and there are some reenacting groups in Europe (where this was filmed) who do wonderful historic looks.  Why not talk to them?  Sigh.   I understand, of course, that this is TV, but still, I think they could have been a bit less Hollywood in the costume department!

Now, my disclaimer here is that if any of theses things had been worn by a random SCAdian at an event, I would not be bothered in by it.  Why?  Because we all play the game at different levels.  (Unless they were wearing them and making claims they were completely authentic costumes).  However, I had higher expectations of the History channel, who has access to many historical experts and has the budget to put some work into it.  And you know, they are presenting this as History so I think I have the right to nit-pick a little. 

Below I am have collected some of the preview photos from from the film along with my first thoughts and ideas of what similar things that I wish had been done instead, things that at least refer back, in some way, to bits of archeological information that we do have.

Picture
Picture
I am not even going to comment on the leather used in this show, as I know nothing about period leather items outside of accessories.  I do, however, find it hard to believe that a corset style garment (leather or not) is a bit out of the realm of reality. 

In an effort to be positive, I will at least say I like the hand stitched details at the edges (whip stitching).  But is that two overlapping rows of rickrack I see in the detail above right? 

What baffles me the most about this costume is her under tunic.  I am not even sure what that is supposed to be.  It looks knit, not woven, like a summer sweater or shawl.  I've seen nothing even remotely close to this anywhere.  Even the Wabengewebe weave from Coppergate or the medieval huck weaves is not this open and, well, weird.  (http://www.medievaltextiles.org/gallery/bing2000b.gif and http://www.medievaltextiles.org/gallery/mckenna2002.gif )


Picture
 Personally, I tend to stay away from teals (yes, I have a teal aprondress, but it was fabric I already had that I needed to use, and I would not set out to purchase that color for this type of garb).  Despite that, I do not think this color is completely unrealistic, as this could feasibly be achieved with woad overdyed with weld.

As for what would I have done?  If I wanted her in leather I think I would have gone with a tunic rather than this more feminine cut garment (I know, it is so not Hollywood to even consider that).  The under tunic would have been a wool (without a lacy pattern, lol).  And the color would have been something more common or just undyed (after all there were many shades of wool available and it could have been a lovely brown or grey rather than white).  Personally, I would you wear an expensive/hard-to-produce (and therefor rare) color into battle?


Picture
I can find a bit more right about this one than the previous costume.  The colors, to start with, are nice and very achievable with indigo or woad dyes.  I also love the herringbone stitching on the border of the cloak.  There are extant examples of that stitch so it is a lovely touch.

Aesthetically, the mottled coloring of the cloak works for me, but I do not envision that as something often practiced in period.  Perhaps something done by a novice dyer would look that way, but I have an idea that this is a highborn lady and likely fabric would be excellently crafted.  Is this supposed to be felted?  I think a heavy weave would have been prettier and more suitable.

I am not sure if the decorations applied to it are supposed to be unspun silk (something that was used in embroidery in other parts of the world, though I cannot think of a reference for it in the Viking area/era) or wool.  There were shaggy wool cloaks in period ( http://www.medievaltextiles.org/gallery/abarria2002.gif ), but even then, it was the whole cloak and not just a decorative element.
Now, I would not suggest these design elements would never happen, but I will say, it actually does not make sense to me.  The top of it makes it appear to be jewelry (pins or brooches of some sort), but the locks of whatever below that are clearly stitched down.

Ok, let us talk about the underdress now.  Again, the color is very nice.  The fabric appears to be either silk, or something pretending to be silk, based on the drape of the sleeve, the slightly crepey texture, and the sheen.  Strips of silk are not uncommon in Viking finds, but they tend to be heavier than this appears and they are applied as decoration (trim) or small accessories such as caps (such as the Coppergate cap), rather than used as whole garments.  I would have considered a fine linen or even a very fine wool for this dress, with either being functional choice that can drape well.  Linen can have a lovely sheen if the weave is fine and the fabric mangled (smoothed as with a glass smoothing stone and whalebone board).

The sleeves are pleated which is not my preferred way to recreate something like this, but there examples of pleats in extant garments as you can see here: http://urd.priv.no/viking/smokkr.html

The item that truly baffles me, however, is the neck line.  I am not even going to theorize on that.  I will say, however, that instead of that that bizarre arrangement, I would have opted for embroidery at the neck.
Picture
Above is a photo of extant Viking era embroidery from the book Viking Artefaks.  Elaborate, and real, and could have been embroidered with silk for the shiny effect they are getting from the locks of silk/wool used in this costume.

Picture
Now, what do I really love about that last photo?  The loom!  The character is standing in front of a warp weighted loom with a lovely piece of weaving on it.  I love that they displayed the correct method of weaving and the colors are nice and this part of the image makes me rather happy.

In the episode last night, one of the characters was teaching her daughter to weave on a warp-weighted loom.  That was the type of thing I was hoping to see a bit more of in this series.




Picture
I will say I do not understand this one at all.  I am not sure what the cloak fabric is even supposed to be and maybe there is something I am missing about Earl Haraldson's wife, but where they heck did she get that much kohl?  ;-)

Honestly, I do not even know what I would do to make this one better....

Picture
This one has some potential, at least.  I love the fabric.  I love the herringbone weave.  The construction, from what I can see in this image, seems to be from geometric panels - almost a Eura dress with the panels below the yoke being pleated.  It is different, but I can buy into at least the idea of this garment (and likewise with the white shift she wore in last night's episode, as it had a similar construction).

I actually think I saw something a bit similar to this on someone at an SCA event one time.  She was doing Russian or Slavic, if memory serves, but I would not swear to it as it was many years ago.  Regardless, I could maybe see this one as feasible, even if I have not seen something in my research that would cause me to come up with this design.

ETA - Ffride on one of the Viking forums just pointed out the following source - http://web.comhem.se/~u41200125/Uvdal31.html and that is what I was thinking of when I said I thought I saw something like this before.

Picture
As for these.... well, I can live happily with the underdresses and the colors are certainly appropriate.  As for the layer on top, loose flapp bits are just not practical to me.  Even had the show gone with the rectangular panel style theory for the aprondresses (one narrow panel in the front, one in the back, held with straps, brooches and likely belted at the waist) it would have made sense a bit more sense.   Actually, I will be honest, I think these are not out of the realm of possible, but I do find them both impractical and visually unappealing.

And it is very sad that what I see as the nicest piece of garb was only on the screen for a mere moment last night!  A dark red apron dress (it even has some sort of diamond pattern to it, even if the pattern itself is too large for my taste) with a natural shift with what appears to be some sort of heavy stitching over the seams.  This works for me.  I do wish she had tortoise brooches, but I can still at least enjoy this interpretation of Viking era attire.

(Images from The Vikings are from http://photos.redeyechicago.com/redeye-vikings-on-history-channel-early-photos-20130109/ )
Picture
Of course, despite my critique, I will be watching the next episode.  The show was, as I mentioned from the start, entertaining.  ;-)
4 Comments
FlorentineScot link
3/4/2013 06:24:17 am

nice! Just the kind of critique (even if you claim it's knee-jerk!). The one garment that I was most interested in, you didn't touch on! Alas.

Reply
Alfrun
3/4/2013 09:11:54 am

LOL, which garment is it?

Reply
Una Rangvaldsdottir
7/25/2013 03:12:58 pm

Hey, regarding Siggy's khol-lined eyes. There is a travel report of an Jewish trader who visited Hedeby/Haithabu in the 10th century (so ~200 years later then when The Vikings are supposed to be happening) and he did describe the residents of Hedeby: "Artificial eye make-up is another peculiarity; when they wear it their beauty never disappears, indeed it is enhanced in both men and women." So it is not totally a-historical. I agree with everything else you say, though :)

Reply
Carlos Francisco Ardila Sánchez
12/17/2018 08:33:13 am

Gracias quisiera saber cuándo continuan los siguientes episodios

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About Me

    I am mother to a billion cats and am on journey to recreate the past via costume, textiles, culture and food.

    A Wandering Elf participates in the Amazon Associates program and a small commission is earned on qualifying purchases. 
    ​

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    March 2021
    February 2021
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012

    Categories

    All
    12th Night
    14th Century
    AEthelmearc
    Aprondress
    Awards
    Bog Dress
    Bronze Age
    Dance
    Dance Name
    Distaff
    Dyeing
    Embroidery
    Fiber Arts
    Flax Growing
    Food
    Glass
    Haberci
    Headcoverings
    Inspirations
    In The News
    Library
    List Of Links
    Machine Embroidery
    Metal Clay
    Mid Month Inspiration
    Migration Era/Iron Age
    My Documents
    Ottoman
    Ottoman Fabrics
    Pennsic
    Publications
    Research
    Rigid Heddle
    Sca
    SCA Camping
    SCA Forestry
    Sca Name
    Sca Newcomer
    Sewing
    Sheep
    Spinning
    Textile Charts
    Tips
    Totally Not SCA
    Viking
    Viking Bead Research
    Viking Costume: Beyond The Myth
    Viking Swatch Book
    Viking Textiles Looking Deeper
    Weaving
    Wool


      Email Updates

    Subscribe to Newsletter

    Blogroll of SCA & Costume Bloggers

    Below is a collection of some of my favorite places online to look for SCA and historic costuming information.

    More Amie Sparrow - 16th Century German Costuming


    Gianetta Veronese - SCA and Costuming Blog

    Grazia Morgano - 16th Century A&S

    Mistress Sahra -Dress From Medieval Turku 

    Hibernaatiopesäke

    Loose Threads: Cathy's Costume Blog

    Mistress Mathilde Bourrette - By My Measure: 14th and 15th Century Costuming

    More than Cod: Exploring Medieval Norway

    RSS Feed


Proudly powered by Weebly